College football weekend preview: The Holy War

The Holy War

Saturday night in Provo is when it all comes down – or does it? This year things seem a little bit different. The same two teams will be playing in what Utah Utes Coach Kyle Whittingham called, “The single biggest sporting event in the state of Utah.” But the timing is off and the meaning is different.

The game between the two Utah football powerhouses is traditionally played in November as the last regular season game of the year, but this year it will be played in September as the third game of the season.

There are almost always implications for final conference standings, and there is frequently a conference title on the line; but not this year. For the first time ever, BYU and Utah will be playing each other in football without being members of the same conference. The University of Utah is a member of the PAC-12 and BYU’s football team is now independent of conference affiliation.

However, the game is still a BIG DEAL here in the state of Utah.

Since the hiring of Whittingham at the University of Utah and Bronco Mendenhall at BYU, the two teams have played each other six times with each team winning three of them. Five of the six games have been decided by a touchdown or less than seven points, two of them went into overtime and last year, the game was decided on the last play of the game as Utah was up by one. BYU attempted a 42-yard field, but it was blocked by Brandon Burton to preserve the victory for Utah. The one game that was decided by more than seven points came in 2008, during the Mendenhall versus Whittingham era – the year that Utah defeated Alabama in the BCS Sugar Bowl.

This year, the game looks to be another close, exciting one. Both teams won their opening game and both teams lost last week. Both teams look strong on defense and both teams are struggling on offense. Both teams have new offensive coordinators and both teams feel that their offense has the potential to make significant improvements.

Offensively the two teams are different in their current strengths. Through the first two games Utah has done well with their running game, but they have struggled with their passing game. Utah running back John White IV has run the ball for 206 yards through the first two games, but their offense is undergoing a change in scheme wherein they were running a spread offense and with the hire of Norm Chow they are now running a pro-style offense.

Also of note, Utah quarterback Jordan Wynn had surgery on the shoulder of his throwing arm after injuring it during the game against BYU last year, but Wynn has said multiple times that his shoulder is now 100 percent and he showed significant improvement last Saturday against USC.

BYU has shown promise with their passing game, especially with the accuracy of quarterback Jake Heaps. On the other hand, they have not been able to establish the run against either of their opponents this year.

Last week against Texas, BYU only had 43 yards rushing. During his press conference this week, Mendenhall said, “The biggest thing that will be helpful to Jake [Heaps] and our offense is to come out swinging and run the ball more effectively … He’s carrying too much of the load.”

The game will be broadcast live on ESPN 2 with kickoff scheduled for 7:15 pm. The game will also be rebroadcast at 11 p.m. on BYUtv. Surprisingly the game has not yet sold out.

Around the Country

There are two games featuring a ranked team on both sides of the field. The first one played out Thursday night as No. 25 Mississippi State hosted No. 3 LSU. The game was a defensive battle most of the way through. LSU led by three at the end of the third quarter 9-6, but the Tigers took over in the 4th quarter, scoring 10 points to win the game 19-6.

Saturday night boasts a game that many people believe to have National Championship implications as No. 1 Oklahoma goes to Tallahassee, Florida to face No. 5 Florida State. This will be the first difficult game of the season for both teams, yet both teams feel they have a schedule advantage.

Oklahoma did not play last week so they had two weeks to prepare for the Seminoles. After losing last year’s starting quarterback Christian Ponder to the NFL, Florida State benefited from having a second game to work out all the issues with their offense. Kickoff is scheduled for 6 p.m. and the game will be broadcast live on ABC.

Dixie State

Dixie State will host Simon Fraser University, a Division II team from Burnaby, Canada in their first conference game of the season.

Simon Fraser University opened conference play last week with a 35-28 loss to Western Oregon. The Red Storm has the luxury of starting off conference play at home as they could use a jump-start to their season. Kickoff is scheduled for 6:05 p.m.


It’s homecoming week in Cedar City and the Thunderbirds will host the Texas-San Antonio Road Runners. The Thunderbirds are coming off an exciting win over a ranked Sacramento State last Saturday.

The Road Runners also have a 1-1 record as they lost by three points last week to McMurry 21-24. Homecoming festivities include a concert and fireworks Friday night starting at 7:30 p.m. and a parade Saturday afternoon at 2 p.m., and culminate with the football game, which starts at 6 p.m.

[email protected]

 Copyright 2011 St. George News. This material may not be published or rewritten without written consent.

Free News Delivery by Email

Would you like to have the day's news stories delivered right to your inbox every evening? Enter your email below to start!


  • LaMarcus September 16, 2011 at 11:11 am

    Why do they call it the Holy War? Does one school represent good and the other evil? I thought the BYU vs Notre Dame was the Holy War. Maybe call it the Root Beer drinkers vs. the Beer drinkers or something like that.

  • Leo Wright September 16, 2011 at 2:35 pm

    Well sure one school represents good and the other represents evil. The question is which is which. I know a lot of people that will tell you Utah is good and BYU is evil and I know a lot of people that will tell it to you the other way around. The 2 schools are actually more connected than a lot of people realize. BYU’s President is a Utah graduate and Utah’s president is a BYU graduate. Whittingham, Utah’s head coach, graduated from BYU and their offensive coordinator may have graduated from the U, but he spent a long time as Offensive coordinator at BYU. Both schools even have the same origin the University of Deseret. In 1876 there was a brake off, Brigham Young academy which later became BYU. The University of Deseret then changed it’s name to the University of Utah in 1982.

  • Not a Mormon September 16, 2011 at 5:52 pm

    The bigger questions is, in fact, who cares? These are Utah teams playing. Even worse, one of them is a Mormon team. I hope they tie 0-0 and lose every other game they play.

    • TSM (fictitious name, edited) September 17, 2011 at 4:11 pm

      I care ! I went to both schools and I must say, The U. is just better! I was a student and also taught there. The only reason I went to BYU was I was an apostle and got the Mormon discount !

      • Jon Martin September 18, 2011 at 11:27 am

        The mormon discount? Well shoot, how do I become an “apostle” than?

  • bill leavitt September 17, 2011 at 4:07 pm

    They call it the holy war because the U is closer to LDS Church headquarters and therefore more “holy” than the team down south. U alumni also pay more in Net tithing than do the team down south Alum. Also U Institute students read the BOM more thoroughly than does the average BYU Institute student.. Its sad to say BYU is slipping into the devil’s den of iniquity, and the average length of thier shorts rises one inch a year. I saw a Y student flip someone off once. It was just atrocious. Max Hall is now a 4th string quarterback BTW..

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.