Shutdown: ‘Paralysis in Washington’ causes counties to ask governor for aid

ST. GEORGE – Washington County and neighboring counties have declared local states of emergency due to negative economic impact caused by the government shutdown of national parks and related lands.

The Washington County Commission issued the resolution Monday at the Washington County Administrative Building. County commissioners from Garfield, Iron, Kane, Sevier, Wayne, San Juan and Grand counties, and the Arizona counties of Coconino and Mohave also participated in person or over the phone.

The Washington County resolution states that approximately 3 million people visit Zion National Park annually, and that “a significant number of residents in Washington County rely on the tourism industry created by Zion visitors for income.”

In addition to Washington County, Iron, Kane and Garfield counties have also issued states of local emergency due to the financial impact of the shutdown. Other Utah counties are considering similar resolutions, Miller said.

While Zion National Park primarily resides in Washington County, it also reaches into Kane and Iron Counties. Bryce Canyon National Park rests in Garfield County; Canyonlands National Park is in Garfield, Wayne and Grand counties; Arches National Parks is in Grand County; and Capitol Reef National Park covers parts of Wayne, Garfield, Sevier and Emery counties.

There are many national monuments and recreation areas scattered across Utah as well. Among those noted in Southern Utah are Cedar Breaks in Iron County and Glen Canyon (Lake Powell) which stretches through parts of San Juan, Kane, Garfield and Wayne counties, these are also closed due to the shutdown.

What’s really disgusting is it’s not just the parks (the government) has tried to shut down, its the whole public lands,” Gardner said. “You have national forest campgrounds, BLM campgrounds; anything that has a federal deal attached to it.”

The shutdown comes at the worst time for tourism-based industries, as the fall season provides significant gains that allow businesses like hotels and restaurants the ability to operate during the slower winter season. Without this income, many business will be forced to layoff employees or may even close their doors.

Springdale and Washington County

“This is the time of year that (Springdale’s) gift shops and galleries do really well,” Washington County Commissioner Alan Gardner said. “The (tourists) are spending more money now than in the summer.”

Zion Park Boulevard, empty, since government shutdown closes Zion National Park, impacts park's gateway town of Springdale, Utah, Oct. 2, 2013 | Photo by Dan Mabbutt, St. George News
Zion Park Boulevard, empty, since government shutdown closes Zion National Park, impacts park’s gateway town of Springdale, Utah, Oct. 2, 2013 | Photo by Dan Mabbutt, St. George News

Springdale sees as many as 10,000 people a day, Springdale Town Councilman Mark Chambers said. Instead of seeing packed streets, “we’re seeing empty sidewalks and empty parking lots. We don’t know what the total financial impact will be till we get through this.”

Due to the park closure and the dramatic reduction in visitors, Chambers said hotel and restaurant employees are having their hours reduced this week.

“It’s unfortunate that the paralysis in Washington is affecting people in the service industry of our community,” Springdale Town Manager Rick Wixom said. “They’re the one’s being hurt.”

Chambers and Wixom also said that an international tourism trend of visiting Utah’s national parks may be broken by the bad impression left by the shutdown.

“Those tourists patterns are hard to rebuild,” Wixom said.

Despite the closure of the park, though, Springdale remains open to visitors.

“Come up to Springdale.” Chambers said. “We’re open for business.”

Iron County

“Its been quite a troubling weekend,” Iron County Commissioner Dave Miller said in relation to the drop in tourism in the region.

“A lot of Iron County is a corridor to Zion and Bryce,” Miller said. “Our economic base is being impacted significantly. This is the most highly trafficked time of the year.”

Cedar Breaks National Monument is currently closed due to the government shutdown. Miller said the Iron County Sheriff’s Office is paying attention to the area because of potential road hazards caused by people who park the road and take photos of the area. Why are they on the road and not parking in areas off the road? Miller said it was due to scenic lookouts along the road being fenced off to public access during the closure.

The Iron County Sheriff’s Office, and county sheriffs in general, are responsible for the health, safety and welfare of the people in their county, Miller said. Because of this, they are “intricately tied to any significant economic disruption” that affects the people of their respective counties.

In Iron County’s case, Miller said the sheriff’s office could also provide law enforcement, EMS and search and rescue operations in lieu of the National Park Service if necessary.

Garfield County

The Garfield County Sheriff’s Office released a statement Monday evening that the county, along with other aforemented Utah counties, has petitioned Gov. Herbert to declare a local state of emergency for the counties negatively impacted by the closure of the national parks, monuments and recreation areas.

Locked out of the national park, tourists walk to a privately-owned piece of land set along the canyon's rim to get a view of Bryce Canyon National Park, Bryce Canyon, Utah, Oct. 2, 2013 | Photo courtesy of Rudy's Inn, St. George News
Locked out of the national park, tourists walk to a privately-owned piece of land set along the canyon’s rim to get a view of Bryce Canyon National Park, Bryce Canyon, Utah, Oct. 2, 2013 | Photo courtesy of Rudy’s Inn, St. George News

“Tourism is responsible for 70 percent of the economy in Garfield County and 90 percent of the land is federally owned. With three national park boundaries within Garfield County, Bryce Canyon, Capitol Reef and Canyonlands, as well as Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument and Glen Canyon National Recreation Area the economic impact has been devastating to our local businesses in an already struggling economy.”

Garfield County Commissioners said at the meeting in Washington County that the closure of Bryce Canyon is heavily impacting hoteliers and others who depend on the flow of tourists for their livelihood.

“It’s really serious here,” Garfield County Commissioner Claire Ramsey said. “Its affecting us big time.”

Ramsey said the biggest employer in the county is Ruby’s Inn, which has estimated it is now losing $100,000 a day due to the shutdown. “And that’s just one business,” he said.

Some businesses in Tropic have nearly shutdown due to the drop in visitors. Panguitch is also being hurt, Ramsey said.

No love lost for Washington D.C.

“Its an abuse of power,” Miller said. “We have a big bully in the White House trying to hurt us.”

Miller also called measures taken to keep the national parks and related venues closed “partisan” and “vindictive” on the part of the federal government and President Barack Obama in particular.

“I am disappointed in the Senate and the president,” Miller said. “They’d better grow up and be leaders.”

Last week the House passed legislation that would provide funding to parts of the federal government, including the National Park Service. However, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, D-Nevada, has stated the Senate will not vote on cherry-picked funding measures. Furthermore, the president has stated he would veto any such items if they cross his desk.

The battle between the Republican-controlled House and the Democrat-controlled Senate is over the Affordable Care Act which the Republicans in the House seek to defund and delay as a part of a continual funding resolution. However, the Democrats will not support such a measure. Any new spending resolution must be passed in whole and include funding for the ACA.

Until one side caves or compromises the shutdown continues.

The pinnacle of our problem lays at the feet of our president,” Ramsey said. “We’re being held hostage.”

“(The federal government) is going to the full extent it can to make it as hard on everybody as possible,” Gardner said. “They have gone the ultimate length to make this as difficult for people as they can. It’s strictly a political thing Obama is doing.”

Gardner added the mess the government is creating “underscores the need to get these lands turned over to the state like was promised in the enabling act.”

The resolution passed by Washington County has been declared in accordance with Utah Code, which authorizes Washington County to provide “all appropriate aid and assistance in relation to the proclamation.”

Gardner said the resolution opens the door to getting potential aid or action from the state, along with whatever measures may need to be taken to try and negate the affects of the closures.

As of Monday evening, a spokesman for the officer said the county resolutions were “being reviewed.”

A copy of the Washington County resolution can be found here.

Related posts:

Email: [email protected]

Twitter: @MoriKessler

Copyright St. George News, LLC, 2013, all rights reserved.



Free News Delivery by Email

Would you like to have the day's news stories delivered right to your inbox every evening? Enter your email below to start!


  • Bender October 7, 2013 at 11:25 pm

    Alan Gardner keeps telling the big lie and hoping that his electorate will be stupid enough to believe his self serving lies.
    Read the act:
    “the people inhabiting said proposed State do agree and declare that they forever disclaim all right and title to the unappropriated public lands lying within the boundaries thereof.”
    and decide how clear the language is.
    The state of Utah was acquired by federal government at the end of the Mexican War by The Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo. We Mormon settlers squatted on lands when we moved here. Eventually we gained title to every bit of land that could be brought under cultivation, mainly irrigated lands. In addition, at statehood, Utah was given title to 7.5 million acres (out of 53 million total) to fund higher and special education. More than half of it was pissed away at fire sale prices to the politically connected before the legislature in the 1990s reigned in the abuse. The federal government retained title to the rest. At no time was it promised to swarmy county politicians to be managed as they see fit.
    Washington County Tea Party Republicans are reaping the discord that they have sown.

  • Jane October 7, 2013 at 11:52 pm

    I really wish that in times when the federal Government has “issues,” the lands should be turned back over to the States until the issue is resolved. States have to have a Balanced budget it is demanded of them by the Federal Government, so when the Federal Government can’t get a Balanced budget, the Lands should go to those (the states) who basically have one. Besides isn’t the US Govt. the People’s Govt.? So aren’t the Lands the People’s lands? I really think that the land should go back to the State and open up because it is the State that is hurt, not the Fed.’s on the hill…

  • truthseeker October 8, 2013 at 3:39 am

    To Jane, yea I agree. Sadly, the govt we once had, is not the govt we currently have. Nor can we use the system to propose changes. It’s a failed system. We are told its a govt for the people by the people so we believe it and get marched into the slaughter house. I posted on one of the other many shut down articles about the govt now. It’s not America, its AmeriKa. A govt For us, by us?- na, for special interests and hidden agendas, by mega corporation and international bankers… In a time of deceit, telling the truth is a revolutionary act.

  • Karen October 8, 2013 at 6:58 am

    I’m sure Alan Gardner and the Washington County Commission would love to get hold of federal lands so they can sell them off to the highest bidder. A perfect example is the monster homes of The Ledges looming over Snow Canyon State Park. The land used to belong to the Park but the Washington County Commission saw fit to force a “trade” of that land so the developer could have nice views for his monster homes. It also destroyed what used to be a family friendly trail that skirts the edge. Now the trail drops down a steep slope so the golfers and home owners aren’t troubled by those pesky Utahns who used to own the land. I’m more than happy to have the federal government protect Utah for all Americans. I have issues with the federal government on other issues, but land is not one of them.

  • Kris October 8, 2013 at 9:01 am

    I :hate to say this, but we need to suck it up, even if we are taking a big hit. I think about all the people who are out there unemployed, can’t find work and suffering before the government shut down. The government is only focusing on their own workers and no one else. They say they care, but they don’t or they would stop this nonsense. This is a stunt to piss people off in order to get the pressure to reopen the government. We need to stop all the wasteful spending and get a budget in place. I am not going to get into the health care issue because that is just an excuse, they could stayed shut down, if they don’t care about the American People as a whole. Employees don’t deserve a paycheck if they didn’t work, they are not going to pay all these people in America who don’t qualify for unemployment and don’t have work. THEY WEREN”T WORKING> They need to stop acting like children and do what they are paid to do THEIR JOB. START THINKING OF THE AMERICAN PEOPLE AS A WHOLE.
    Just a follow up note, I am glad the President could go on his trip, look how much money was saved, we need every penny if the Federal Government mandates the States to balance their budget, then they should do the same.

  • Brobee October 8, 2013 at 9:40 am

    The way I see it, why should we pay for a county that voted themselves into this mess in the first place?

  • Greta Hyland October 8, 2013 at 11:13 am

    That State can’t manage these lands. They can’t even manage the State Parks. Of course the county commissioners are throwing the land take-over into this article. Oh, and to belabor the obvious, it was House Republicans who held up the government and caused the shutdown, not the President. Nice try Miller, Ramsey, and Gardener. That’s cute.

  • JULI October 12, 2013 at 9:30 pm

    I enjoyed reading your letter to the editor. I must say I was surprised, and it is refreshing to know not everyone in Washington County is still drinking the same Kool-Aid as Gardner, Ramsey and Miller. Gardner did you really think the shutdown would not have an impact on the economy of Washington County? You can thank your Republican good ole boys! Three years and 42 attempts and what have they accomplished? Health care has a higher rating now than three years ago. Obama thanks you! Oh and I can’t forget the Republicans have set a record for an all time low approval rating of 28%. Instead of focusing on the economy, and deficit the Republican party was to busy pushing their own agenda. Don’t point the finger at Obama. He agreed in 2011 to the sequester and the spending bill he endorsed was the Republicans. This country is not done feeling the impact of the government shutdown. All those federal workers who are furloughed…..they will be drawing unemployment and not spending money to stimulate the economy. Gardner look in the mirror and what do you see KARMA!!!!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.